| Year | Player | Voters | Ballots | Required | Votes | Pct. | Ind. | Category |
| 1942 | Rogers Hornsby | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 182 | 0.7811 | Y | Player |
| 1942 | Frank Chance | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 136 | 0.5837 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Rube Waddell | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 126 | 0.5408 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Ed Walsh | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 113 | 0.4850 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Miller Huggins | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 111 | 0.4764 | N | Manager |
| 1942 | Ed Delahanty | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 104 | 0.4464 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Johnny Evers | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 91 | 0.3906 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Wilbert Robinson | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 89 | 0.3820 | N | Manager |
| 1942 | Mickey Cochrane | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 88 | 0.3777 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Frankie Frisch | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 84 | 0.3605 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Hugh Duffy | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 77 | 0.3305 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Herb Pennock | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 72 | 0.3090 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Clark Griffith | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 71 | 0.3047 | N | Pioneer/Executive |
| 1942 | Jimmy Collins | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 68 | 0.2918 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Rabbit Maranville | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 66 | 0.2833 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Hughie Jennings | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 64 | 0.2747 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Mordecai Brown | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 63 | 0.2704 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Eddie Plank | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 63 | 0.2704 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Joe McGinnity | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 59 | 0.2532 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Fred Clarke | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 58 | 0.2489 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Roger Bresnahan | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 57 | 0.2446 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Chief Bender | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 55 | 0.2361 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Ray Schalk | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 53 | 0.2275 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Pie Traynor | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 45 | 0.1931 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Ross Youngs | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 44 | 0.1888 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Frank Baker | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 39 | 0.1674 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Dazzy Vance | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 37 | 0.1588 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Bill Terry | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 36 | 0.1545 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Joe Tinker | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 36 | 0.1545 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Addie Joss | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 33 | 0.1416 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Johnny Kling | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 15 | 0.0644 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Nap Rucker | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 15 | 0.0644 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Babe Adams | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 11 | 0.0472 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Hank Gowdy | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 8 | 0.0343 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Kid Nichols | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 5 | 0.0215 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Jesse Burkett | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 4 | 0.0172 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Harry Heilmann | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 4 | 0.0172 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Eddie Grant | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 3 | 0.0129 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Branch Rickey | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 3 | 0.0129 | N | Pioneer/Executive |
| 1942 | Zack Wheat | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 3 | 0.0129 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Donie Bush | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 2 | 0.0086 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Sam Crawford | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 2 | 0.0086 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Pepper Martin | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 2 | 0.0086 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Roger Peckinpaugh | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 2 | 0.0086 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Bobby Wallace | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 2 | 0.0086 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Ginger Beaumont | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 1 | 0.0043 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Jake Beckley | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 1 | 0.0043 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Joe Boley | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 1 | 0.0043 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Bill Bradley | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 1 | 0.0043 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Lave Cross | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 1 | 0.0043 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Bill Dineen | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 1 | 0.0043 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Jack Dunn | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 1 | 0.0043 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Kid Elberfeld | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 1 | 0.0043 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Red Faber | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 1 | 0.0043 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Billy Hamilton | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 1 | 0.0043 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Babe Herman | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 1 | 0.0043 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Waite Hoyt | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 1 | 0.0043 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Joe Kelley | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 1 | 0.0043 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Dickey Kerr | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 1 | 0.0043 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Arlie Latham | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 1 | 0.0043 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Bobby Lowe | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 1 | 0.0043 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Sherry Magee | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 1 | 0.0043 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Deacon Phillippe | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 1 | 0.0043 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Edd Roush | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 1 | 0.0043 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Amos Rusie | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 1 | 0.0043 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Germany Schaefer | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 1 | 0.0043 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Everett Scott | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 1 | 0.0043 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Harry Steinfeldt | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 1 | 0.0043 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Fred Tenney | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 1 | 0.0043 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Bill Wambsganss | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 1 | 0.0043 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Hack Wilson | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 1 | 0.0043 | N | Player |
| 1942 | Joe Wood | BBWAA | 233 | 175 | 1 | 0.0043 | N | Player |